For years, U.S. importers treated the U.S.-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA) as optional. With average duty rates from Canada and Mexico hovering around 2.8%, many companies ran a simple cost-benefit calculation:

• Low duties = minimal cost of non-qualification
• USMCA qualification = administrative burden, documentation, audits, risk

In most cases, that math made sense.

But in 2025, the calculus has changed. Dramatically.

The Historic View: USMCA Was Often Not Worth It

USMCA (formerly NAFTA) provides duty-free treatment to qualifying goods originating in Canada or Mexico. But to claim that benefit, importers must:

• Obtain and retain detailed certificates of origin
• Ensure supply chain transparency around origin and production
• Maintain documentation for up to five years
• Survive potential CBP audits or partner government challenges

When duty rates were modest, most companies asked a simple question: "Is this worth the risk and effort?" For a 2.8% savings, many concluded it wasn’t. After all, the penalties for false claims under USMCA can be steep, and supply chain origin validation can be murky.

The Game-Changer: A 25% Blanket Tariff

In March 2025, the U.S. administration imposed a 25% tariff on all goods entering from Canada and Mexico that are not USMCA-qualified. The political justification was framed around economic nationalism, but the result is clear:

Companies that previously ignored USMCA are now facing an immediate and significant cost increase.

If you're not using USMCA, you're now paying:

• 25% tariff (instead of 0%) on qualifying goods
• With no additional time to restructure your sourcing

This has made USMCA compliance not just worthwhile, but mandatory for many importers.

Why USMCA Qualification Is Harder Than It Looks

Qualifying under USMCA is not as simple as asking your supplier for a certificate. It requires:

Origin Determination

• Does your product qualify based on the rules of origin?
• Does it meet the regional value content (RVC) requirement?
• Does it qualify via a tariff shift or net cost method?

Supplier and Manufacturer Documentation

• Suppliers must be able to prove the origin of materials.
• Complex products (e.g., electronics, automotive components) often require a multi-tier BOM analysis.

Record Keeping and Audit Readiness

• CBP can demand proof of qualification at any time.
• If you can't prove it, you risk penalties plus back duties plus interest.

The Risk of Doing It Wrong

Claiming USMCA improperly can be worse than not claiming it at all. Risks include:

• Denial of preferential treatment (and retroactive duties)
• Penalties for false declarations (civil and criminal)
• Loss of future eligibility
• Disruption of trusted trader programs

In 2025, with a 25% tariff hanging over every non-USMCA shipment, you can't afford to claim unless you can defend it.

What You Need to Do It Right

Robust Master Data

• Accurate HTS classifications
• Country of origin for every component
• Rules of origin mapped to your products

Document Control

• Certificates of origin
• BOMs and cost structures
• Supplier declarations
• Automated retention of USMCA documentation

Workflow and Visibility

• Review and validation processes
• Alerts for missing or expiring documentation
• Change management for shifting supplier sources

How 3rdwave Supports USMCA Qualification

3rdwave was designed for cross-border compliance. Here's how we support importers responding to the 2025 tariff shock:

Origin Qualification Framework

• Determine origin qualification via RVC, tariff shift, or set rules
• Embed rules into master product data

Supplier & BOM Traceability

• Map BOMs to source countries
• Roll up origin qualification at the product level

Document Repository & Expiry Management

• Store and manage certificates of origin
• Alert for renewals, missing documentation, and risk areas

Risk Identification

• Flag non-qualified products
• Simulate landed cost with and without USMCA
• Forecast duty exposure if claims are denied

Final Thought: You No Longer Have a Choice

When duty rates were 2.8%, USMCA was a "nice to have."

Now, with a 25% penalty for non-qualification, it's a strategic imperative.

But qualification is complex, and the risks of getting it wrong are real. To play in this new world, importers need systems, data, documentation, and discipline.

3rdwave was built for this moment. Contact us to learn more about 3rdwave as your solution to today's tariff challenges.

‍